New home secretary signed letter opposing deportation of foreign criminals, including convicted child rapist

Saturday, 6 September 2025 13:55

By David Murphy

A letter co-signed by Shabana Mahmood MP in 2020, which urged the government to halt a controversial deportation flight to Jamaica, has resurfaced online after her appointment as home secretary.

Shabana Mahmood, the newly appointed home secretary under Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, is facing criticism over a letter she co-signed in 2020 opposing a planned deportation flight carrying convicted foreign nationals. The letter, also signed by then-Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn and dozens of other MPs, specifically raised concerns about the fairness and legality of deporting individuals who may have come to the UK as children or lacked proper legal representation.

Among those due to be deported on that flight was a man convicted of child rape, according to media reports at the time. The inclusion of such individuals has led to renewed criticism from political opponents, with Conservative councillor Jack Rydeheard posting on social media: “How can we trust someone like her to prioritise our safety and tackle illegal immigration? I certainly don’t.”

However, the original letter did not request the release of specific individuals or condone their crimes. Instead, it called for a pause in deportations to ensure due process and fair access to legal advice. The MPs argued that deporting individuals who may not have had the chance to fully appeal their cases risked violating legal and human rights standards.

The 2020 deportation flight itself became a flashpoint in public discourse. It took place during the Covid-19 pandemic, and shortly after the Windrush Scandal had cast a spotlight on government deportation practices. Several people due to be deported had their removals halted by court injunctions.

A government spokesperson at the time defended the removals, saying: “We make no apology for seeking to remove dangerous foreign criminals to keep the public safe.”

Mahmood, who represents Birmingham Ladywood, has not yet issued a statement in response to the renewed criticism. Her previous work has focused on legal justice and social policy, and she served as shadow justice secretary before her promotion to the home secretary post this week.

Labour has pledged a new approach to immigration that includes stricter border enforcement alongside improved asylum processing. In her new role, Mahmood is expected to oversee the implementation of these pledges.

Do you have a story for us? Want to tell us about something happening in our Borough?

Let us know by emailing newsdesk@rochvalleyradio.com

All contact will be treated in confidence.

More from Local News

Road closures and parking restrictions announced for Bury 10K Running Festival

Drivers urged to plan ahead as Sunday road closures set to impact key routes in Bury and Tottington
The people living around the old asbestos site in Rochdale

It was once an industrial behemoth that employed thousands of Rochdalians – but many knew little of the danger lurking right under their noses.
No progress on new school despite shortage of spaces

The town of Littleborough is in ‘dire need’ of a new secondary school, but progress has been slow since the government halted proceedings in 2022.
Arrest made after string of violent robberies targeting lone women in Greater Manchester

A 52-year-old man from north Manchester has been arrested after ten women were attacked in a spate of handbag robberies across Manchester, Salford and Bury.
New housing development on old school grounds approved

A new housing development will be built on the former grounds of a primary school in Rochdale.
From war veterans to walking footballers Rochdale shines in every corner

I am already a third of the way through my Mayoral year and I am enjoying every minute. To reiterate a key message from my last column, it is such a humbling experience to visit so many inspiring organisations, businesses and volunteers who make up the fabric of our borough.
Rochdale becomes open-air gallery as world-renowned muralists transform town centre

A major international street art festival is underway in Rochdale, turning ten buildings into bold new landmarks as artists from across the globe create murals celebrating the town’s culture and history.
Controversial sheep shelter plan approved

A sheep shelter that has been at the centre of controversy in Rochdale will finally be built after three years of turmoil.
Mass disruption to Bee Network as over 2,000 bus workers plan four-day strike

Bus passengers across Greater Manchester are being warned to expect significant disruption later this month as more than 2,000 workers from the Bee Network prepare to walk out over pay.
Family pay tribute to Mohammed Isa who was murdered last month

The family of a young man fatally stabbed in Bury have paid a moving tribute to him, describing him as “the heartbeat and soul” of their lives.
Tottington High School leadership update as students return for new term

Parents and carers at Tottington High School have been told that David Yates’ absence will continue as the new school year begins.
Sit back and enjoy the view as Rochdale unveils outdoor gallery in town hall square

A new open-air art gallery has been unveiled in front of Rochdale’s historic town hall, offering residents and visitors a place to pause, reflect, and enjoy local creativity.