The controversial plans for a Spar store that don’t seem to go away

Thursday, 15 May 2025 13:30

By George Lythgoe

Abandoned garage on Smithy Bridge Road, Littleborough

The developer who was refused permission to build a new Spar convenience store in Littleborough has lost an appeal.

At the beginning of 2024, James Hall & Co Ltd were denied by Rochdale Council planning committee in their bid to demolish the old Lake Garage off Smithy Bridge Road and replace it with a Spar convenience store and a cash machine.

This was the second time the developer had put forward the proposals to transform the former motor dealership and MOT/car repair garage after a previous refusal.

Despite the design and layout changes, council planning officers still believed there would be safety concerns for pedestrians.

James Hall & Co Ltd reduced the number of site access points from three to one and provided a dedicated pedestrian route to the store entrance. They added that an HGV would only be on the site once a day, at most, and measures would be in place for staff to move vehicles blocking the route in.

The developers said the new store would ‘meet the day-to-day convenience shopping needs of local residents without the need to travel further afield’ and create 30 permanent jobs – 15 full-time and 15 part-time.

But planning officers still had concerns about the manoeuvres required from service vehicles delivering to the store and the lack of parking – creating a safety risk for pedestrians. Following the decision to refuse the plan in January 2024, the developer lodged an appeal a few months later.

In response, the Planning Inspectorate decision read: “I am not satisfied that the proposal would not cause harm to highway safety, and the imposition of a condition relating to a ‘Delivery Management Plan’ would mitigate the overall concerns.

“I acknowledge the appellant’s willingness to provide such detail, but this has not been provided and the supporting statements are again based on assumptions, examples and presumptions of how deliveries could be managed.

“Nevertheless, I agree with the council that it would place an unnecessary burden on them to control in this instance and would only provide a degree of control and certainty.”

The Planning Inspectorate decision on the matter is final and a new planning application would be needed for any future development on the site.

Do you have a story for us? Want to tell us about something happening in our Borough?

Let us know by emailing newsdesk@rochvalleyradio.com

All contact will be treated in confidence.

More from Local News

Seven Sisters tenants reaction to the news they could soon be removed

Billy Jackson has called Rochdale’s Seven Sisters home for 40 years. But shock decision means 2025 will be his final year in the iconic tower blocks.
Festive magic arrives in Bury as North Pole Safari Trail transforms town centre

Free augmented reality trail, festive lights switch-on and family events launch Christmas celebrations in Bury
Replacement mosque plans approved despite concerns about parking

Plans to knock down and rebuild a mosque in Prestwich have been approved despite a 1,630 person petition opposing it.
Andy Burnham ‘taken aback’ by decision to move hundreds out of Seven Sisters towers

Andy Burnham was ‘taken aback’ by a decision to clear Rochdale’s iconic ‘Seven Sisters’ tower blocks, forcing hundreds from their homes.
Nine-bed HMO built ‘without permission’ discovered after neighbours complain

Council enforcement officers discovered a nine-bed HMO had been created without permission after a complaint from neighbours, councillors have heard.
Rochdale’s music legacy takes centre stage with iconic Cargo Studios reunion

Rochdale’s rich musical heritage was centre stage at a packed launch event marking the beginning of a new borough-wide celebration called ‘Rochdale Music Stories’, featuring big names like Peter Hook, Clint Boon and Andy McCluskey.
Naked man stops traffic on Rochdale Road in Bury in shocking mid-morning incident

A naked man caused disruption on a busy Bury road on Wednesday morning, swatting at cars and attempting to open vehicle doors before being detained and taken to hospital.
Seven Sisters tower blocks to be emptied over safety concerns

Residents of the iconic tower blocks that have dominated the skyline of Rochdale since the 1960s have been told they will be evicted due to safety concerns.
Culture Co-op secures £1 million to give Rochdale residents more say over arts and creativity

Rochdale’s Culture Co-op has been awarded £1 million to put local people at the heart of cultural decision-making, as part of a £42 million national programme run by Arts Council England.
Hollin pupils turn happiness into poetry during magical session in Middleton

Middleton Library plays host to spellbinding session with Rochdale’s poet laureate Sammy Weaver
Waugh presses government to ensure grooming inquiry tackles race and class ‘head on’

Rochdale MP Paul Waugh says national grooming inquiry must win survivors’ trust and 'follow the evidence wherever it leads’
Goodbye garlic bread? Sandbrook Park Pizza Hut to shut as 68 UK branches axed

Rochdale’s Pizza Hut restaurant is among dozens of UK branches set to permanently shut, after the company that operated the brand in the UK fell into administration.